Legal Nature of Ethics Codes of Professional Associations

Authors

  • Voronina M. A.

Abstract

problem setting. Basing on modern theoretical development and analysis of current legislation of Ukraine, the article studies the system of social norms, their classification in the law literature, especially corporate norms, and their peculiarities compared to the rules of law by their origin, method of adoption, subjects to which they are applied, acts of will, form of external expression, specific nature of sanctions. The article suggests author’s own conception of the legal nature of the ethics codes of professional associations. Analysis of recent researches and publications. The following representatives of the juridical and social sciences at various times gave their attention to studying of this question in the past and in the modern literature: S. S. Alekseyev, S. A. Aliynyk, T. Y. Vasylevska, V. V. Holovchenko, T. V. Kashanina, B. Lepko, V. L. Medvedeva, V. S. Nersesiants, P. M. Rabinovych, M. I. Rudakevych, O. Y. Finogentova, Y. V. Polozkov, G. P. Chayka, M. V. Cherepanova and others. purposes of research. Determination of the legal nature of the ethics codes of professional associations and their role in civil society depending on subjects who are covered by their action; of peculiarities of legal regulation of the relations associated with the ethical behavior of these subjects; determination of rules, standards, of their behavior with the third parties and in the structure of associations themselves. paper objective. Professional ethics codes comprise ordered ethics prescriptions, which complement provisions of legislative acts, regulating activities of judges, procurators, lawyers, pharmacists, physicians, journalists and other representatives of important and socially significant occupations. The basic reasons conditioning adoption of ethics codes include practical unavailability to regulate on legislative level all the aspects of professional activity of associations by simple preservation of rights and obligations, without taking into account peculiarities of professional behavior of individual groups of specialists. Additionally, the mechanism of adoption of ethics codes without participation of the state is a method of harmonization of relations inside the civil society by the society itself, and it evidencing advantage of the private law over norms of the public law and is an index of the social maturity. Conclusions and prospects for the development. 1. Social norms are the generic term, related to the legal and corporative norms. Corporative norms along with legal norms are the basic normative regulator in the society. 2. The difference of corporative norms from the other social norms consists in their subjective directivity (influence on set of individuals, which belong to definite professional association), methods of their setting (the norms are set by the corporate body, communicated to all participants of corporative relations and are effective upon their official cancellation or upon termination of activity of the organization itself), specific mechanism of corporative coercion. 3. By their own legal nature the ethics codes of professional associations are codified regulatory acts, adopted by the representatives of definite profession containing compulsory moral and ethical prescriptions, ordered in accordance with the specific nature of the activities of professionals union (association) and regulating professional behavior of its participants. 4. The initial normative material in creation of ethics codes are the corporative norms. In the process of regulation of professional association activities, the correlation between corporative norm and legal norm occurs, and it reflects in inclusion of corporative regulator to the mechanisms of legal regulation of social relationships. 5. Ethics codes of professional association are normative and not legal acts, they are adopted by the administrative bodies of professional associations, and not by government bodies, and their implementation is provided by non-juridical methods, which are peculiar only to them. In case when corporative norms of ethics code are used along with the legal norms of the definite sphere of law, the legal liability occurs. In ethics codes the prohibitive and obliging norms are prevailing.

References

Nersesyants v. S. Filosofiya prava: ucheb. dlya vuzov (Philosophy of Law textbook. for universities), Nersesyants v. S, M., Norma, 2009, p. 848.

Pravovedenie (Jurisprudence), Uchebnik, I. N. Bartsits, A. v. vasilev, B. N. Gabrichidze i dr.; pod obsch. red. prof. G. v. Maltseva, M., Izd-vo RAGS, 2003, p. 584.

Aleynik S. A. korporativnyie normyi v rossiyskom prave (Corporate standards in the Russian law), avtoref. dis. ... kand. yurid. nauk, 12.00.01, S. A. Aleynik, Federalnoe gosudarstvennoe obrazovatelnoe uchrezhdenie vyisshego professionalnogo obrazovaniya Rossiyskaya akademiya gosudarstvennoy sluzhbyi pri Prezidente Rossiyskoy Federatsii, M., 2007, p. 24.

kashanina t. v. Korporativnoe pravo (Corporate right), t. v. kashanina, M., NORMA – INFRA, M, 1999, p. 486.

Bukreev v. I., Rimskaya I. N. Etika prava: Ot istokov etiki i prava k mirovozzreniyu, ucheb. posobie (Ethics Law: From the origins of ethics and law to outlook),v. I. Bukreev, I. N. Rimskaya, Moskva, Yurayt, 2000, p. 336.

Malinovskiy A. A. kodeks professionalnoy etiki: ponyatie i yuridicheskoe znachenie (Code of Professional Ethics: concept and legal significance), A. A. Malinovskiy, Zhurnal rossiyskogo prava, 2008, No. 4, pp. 39–44.

Pro pravyla etychnoi povedinky, Zakon Ukrainy vid 17 travnia 2012, No. 4722-vI (About the rules of ethical conduct: Law of Ukraine dated 17 May 2012 р. No 4722-vI), Vidomosti Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy, 2013, No. 14, p. 779.

Kodeks suddivskoi etyky (Code of Judicial Ethics) [Elektronnyi resurs], Rezhym dostupu: http://court.gov.ua/userfiles/kodex%20sud%20etiki(1).pdf.

Pro zatverdzhennia Kodeksu profesiinoi etyky ta povedinky pratsivnykiv prokuratury, Nakaz Heneralnoho prokurora Ukrainy vid 28 lystopada 2012, No. 123 (About approval of Code of Professional Ethics and behavior prosecutors: Prosecutor General Ukraine Decree of 28 November 2012 р. No 123), [Elektronnyi resurs], Rezhym dostupu: http://www.gp.gov.ua/ua/ kodet.html?_m=publications&_t=rec&id=113992.

Pro zatverdzhennia Kodeksu profesiinoi etyky pratsivnyka derzhavnoi podatkovoi sluzhby Ukrainy, Nakaz Derzhavnoi podatkovoi administratsii Ukrainy vid 7 liutoho 2006, N 59 (About approval of the Code of Professional Ethics of the State tax Service of Ukraine, the State tax Administration of Ukraine Decree dated February 7, 2006 g. N 59), [Elektronnyi resurs], Rezhym dostupu: http://search.ligazakon.ua/l_doc2.nsf/link1/GDPI7552.html.

Pro zatverdzhennia Pravyl profesiinoi etyky notariusiv Ukrainy, Nakaz Ministerstva yustytsii Ukrainy vid 14.03.2013 No. 431/5 (About approval of rules of professional ethics notaries Ukraine : Decree of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine of 14.03.2013 No 431/5), Ofitsiinyi visnyk Ukrainy, 2013, No. 24, p. 531.

European Code of Notarial Professional Ethics [Elektronnyi resurs], Rezhym dostupu: http://www.eesc.europa.eu/self-and-coregulation/full.asp?ID=61.

Principles of notarial ethics [Elektronnyi resurs], Rezhym dostupu: http://www.uinl.org/148/ principles-of-notarial-ethics.

Etyka dilovoho spilkuvannia: Kurs lektsii (Ethics in business communication: Lectures), t. k. Chmut, H. L. Chaika, M. P. Lukashevych, I. B. Osechynska, 2-he vyd., stereotyp, k., MAUP, 2003, p. 208.

Cherepanova M. v. Aktualizatsiya eticheskih kodeksov v kontekste sovremennoy kulturyi (Actualization of codes of ethics in the context of contemporary culture), M. v. Cherepanova, Izvestiya Tomskogo politehnicheskogo universiteta, 2013, t.322, No. 6, pp. 92–95.

Finogentova O. E. Sistema eticheskih kodeksov v sovremennoy Rossii, (the system of ethical codes in contemporary Russia).E. Finogentova, E. v. Polozkov, Vestnik Baltiyskogo federalnogo universiteta im. I. Kanta, 2013, N0. 9, pp. 15–21.

vasylevska t. E. kodeksy povedinky deputativ yak instrumenty pidtrymky deputatskoi etyky (Codes of conduct for of Deputies as tools to support parliamentary ethics), t. E. vasylevska, Derzhavne upravlinnia: teoriia ta praktyka, 2013, No. 2, pp. 5–13.

Rohova O. H. Zastosuvannia etychnykh kodeksiv u medytsyni (the application of codes of ethics in medicine), O. H. Rohova, Visnyk Akademii advokatury Ukrainy, 2012, vyp. 2, pp. 30–38.

Cherepanova M. v. transformatsii eticheskih kodeksov v kontekste sovremennoy sotsiokulturnoy sistemyi (transformation codes of ethics in the context of contemporary socio-cultural system), M. v. Cherepanova, Istoricheskie, filosofskie, politicheskie i yuridicheskie nauki, kulturologiya i iskusstvovedenie. Voprosyi teorii i praktiki, tambov, Gramota, 2014, No. 5 (43), v 3 ch., Ch. III, pp. 205–207.

Published

2022-07-20

Issue

Section

Articles